top of page

Cozy Italian restaurant near Times Square NYC

  • Writer: Trattoria Trecolori
    Trattoria Trecolori
  • Aug 26
  • 3 min read

If you find yourself near Times Square, maybe heading to a Broadway show, walking through Midtown’s energy, or showing a friend around the city—you might be asking yourself one essential question:

Where can I find a cozy Italian restaurant near Times Square that doesn’t feel touristy, but feels like home?

Let us introduce you to Trattoria Trecolori, a family-owned gem nestled just a few steps off Broadway, where Italian tradition meets warm hospitality in one of the busiest corners of New York City.

Caprese salad on a white plate with tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil. Held by a hand over a red tablecloth, creating a fresh and vibrant mood.
Italian Classic

A Local Favorite with a Heart When You Are Looking For A Cozy Italian restaurant near Times Square NYC.

There’s something different about Trattoria Trecolori the moment you step in. It’s not just the aroma of freshly baked bread, the clinking of wine glasses, or the soft lighting reflecting off brick walls—it’s the feeling.

That sense of comfort. That "sit down, you’re among friends" feeling.

Locals love it because it’s dependable. Tourists love it because it’s real. And everyone loves it because it serves handmade pasta, classic Italian flavors, and an inviting atmosphere that feels like a true neighborhood escape.

Table set for dining with two glasses, menus, and cutlery on a white tablecloth. Plates and folded napkins are visible in the background.
Classic Place Setting

More Than a Meal—It’s an Experience

In a city full of flashy restaurants and quick grabs, Trattoria Trecolori takes its time—just like Nonna would.

From the first pour of wine to the last spoon of tiramisù, every moment is part of the experience. The staff greets you like family. The food arrives with the kind of care that can’t be faked. And even if you’re just here for one night, the team makes sure you’ll remember it.

Wine bottles with red caps labeled "MASI" are stacked horizontally on a metal rack. The setting is rustic with dim lighting.
Wine Collection

What Makes It So Cozy?

Let’s talk details. What actually makes a place feel cozy in the heart of Manhattan?

  • The ambiance: exposed brick walls, candle-lit tables, white linens, and warm lighting

  • The people: attentive service that doesn’t rush you, but never leaves you waiting

  • The layout: quiet corners, large tables for celebrations, and an overall space that balances intimacy with energy

  • The food: comforting, familiar, and flavorful—without pretense

Whether you’re in heels after a show or sneakers after sightseeing, this is a space where you can breathe, eat, and feel welcome.

Women sharing wine at a restaurant with brick walls. Table set with glasses and cutlery, creating a relaxed dining atmosphere.
Table Conversation

A Menu That Warms the Soul

Let’s be honest—cozy and Italian are best friends. And at Trattoria Trecolori, that bond is expressed through a menu full of timeless dishes made fresh every day.

  • Rigatoni alla Vodka – rich, creamy, and comforting

  • Linguine Garlic & Oil – simple, elegant, and deeply flavorful

  • Eggplant Parmigiana – baked to perfection, just like Sunday dinner at Nonna’s

  • Chicken Marsala – tender chicken in a velvety wine sauce

  • Homemade Cannoli – because no Italian meal is complete without dessert

Vegetarian? Gluten-free? No problem. The menu is thoughtfully curated to offer something for every guest.

A person holds a white plate of gnocchi with tomato sauce, mozzarella, and a basil leaf on a red tablecloth, creating a warm, appetizing scene.
Italian Comfort

Perfect for Any Occasion

You don’t need a reason to dine here—but if you have one, even better:

  • 🎭 Pre-theater dinner: Just minutes from all the top Broadway shows

  • 🥂 Date night: Soft lighting and classic Italian romance

  • 🧳 Out-of-town guests: A truly New York experience without the tourist trap vibe

  • 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 Family dinners: Spacious seating and a kid-friendly menu

  • 🥳 Celebrations: Private dining options and a staff that makes it feel special

If you're looking for a cozy Italian restaurant near Times Square NYC, this isn’t just an option—it’s the right one.

What Guests Are Saying

“We come every time we’re in NYC. Feels like a second home.”“Incredible pasta, amazing service, and not at all a tourist trap.”“The perfect way to start our Broadway night.”

The reviews say it all. Whether it’s your first time or your fiftieth, you’ll feel the heart of this place from your first bite.


Just Steps Away From the Action

Times Square is loud. It’s bright. It’s fast. That’s New York. But in the middle of all that, you can have a quiet, meaningful meal that feels like a pause button.

📍 Trattoria Trecolori 254 W 47th StreetNew York, NY 10036(between 8th Ave and Broadway)



Join Us at the Table

Whether you’re just passing through Midtown or you’re a New Yorker looking for your new go-to, come experience the comfort of Trattoria Trecolori.

This is where memories are made over pasta.Where Broadway stars and locals sit side by side.And where every plate tells a story worth sharing.

Comments

bottom of page