Best Italian Restaurant Times Square: Why Trattoria Trecolori Is a Broadway Classic
- Trattoria Trecolori
- Aug 25
- 3 min read
In the Middle of the Action, a Taste of Real Italy !
Times Square is packed with options, flashy chains, overpriced steakhouses, and rushed tourist traps. But if you’re looking for a real meal, with real flavor and service that actually remembers you, Trattoria Trecolori delivers.
Just steps from Broadway’s biggest theaters, this family-run gem has quietly become a local favorite and a top contender for the best Italian restaurant Times Square has to offer.
Handmade Pasta and Recipes That Don’t Try Too Hard
At Trattoria Trecolori, the focus is on simplicity, quality, and consistency. The pasta is made by hand, the sauces are house-prepared, and the recipes are rooted in decades of family tradition.
Fan favorites include:
Spinach and Ricotta Ravioli in a sage butter sauce
Penne alla Vodka : creamy, balanced, and never too heavy
Gnocchi Pomodoro with fresh basil and light tomato sauce
Fettuccine Alfredo : done the classic way
Rigatoni Bolognese : slow-simmered and flavorful
It’s not flashy, it’s comforting. And that’s exactly what makes it memorable.
Pre-Theater Dinner Done Right
Going to a Broadway show? You’re not alone. Trattoria Trecolori is one of the most popular pre-theater restaurants in Times Square, and for good reason.
Dinner here is paced intentionally, with service that knows how to get you to curtain call without making you feel rushed. Most major theaters are within a 3–5 minute walk, including:
The Majestic Theatre
The Lyric
The Belasco
The Minskoff
The Richard Rodgers
Whether you book a table or walk in early, you’ll enjoy a full meal with time to spare, wine, pasta, espresso, and maybe even dessert.
More Than a Restaurant: A Family Legacy !
Trattoria Trecolori isn’t just another Times Square eatery: It began with Joaquín “Jack” González, whose passion for hospitality and Italian cuisine created the foundation of what the restaurant is today.
After Jack’s passing in 2001, his sons Marco, Víctor, and Phil took over, not to reinvent the place, but to carry the legacy forward. That same warmth and consistency that made Trecolori a neighborhood favorite still defines every plate and every guest interaction.
And that’s why, year after year, Trecolori stays at the top of the list for the best Italian restaurant Times Square can offer.
Don’t Miss the Cannoli !
Let’s talk dessert. Many guests don’t expect it, but the cannoli at Trattoria Trecolori has developed a following of its own. Crisp, filled to order, and never soggy, it’s a must-try if you’re a fan of Italian sweets.
Also worth exploring:
Tiramisù
Ricotta Cheesecake
Espresso and Italian liqueurs
What Makes a Restaurant “The Best”?
In NYC, “best” is personal. For some, it’s about innovation. For others, it’s about views or vibes. But for many, it comes down to this:
Food that’s consistent
Service that feels real
A place where you don’t have to pretend
That’s what Trattoria Trecolori offers. It's not trying to be trendy. It's not chasing headlines. It’s just making good food in a good way, in a great location. And that’s why it's earned its place as one of the best Italian restaurants in Times Square.
Where to Find Us:
📞 Phone: (212) 997-4540🕒 Hours:
Monday–Thursday: 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM
Friday–Saturday: 12:00 PM – 10:30 PM
Sunday: 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM
Reservations are recommended, especially pre-theater and weekends. Book a table here
What Guests Say About the Pasta:
“Exactly what I was craving: simple, fresh pasta without all the tourist trap nonsense. We had gnocchi and ravioli before a show and I couldn’t believe how quiet and cozy it was.” – Grace C., Google Review
“Their penne alla vodka is easily my favorite in Midtown.” – Daniel L., Yelp
