Wicked and Wonderful: The Best Italian Restaurant NYC Awaits After the Show

You’ve just watched Wicked. The lights, the voices, the unforgettable “Defying Gravity” moment, and you’re still buzzing with energy as you step into the Midtown air. Now what? The magic doesn’t have to end at the theater doors.

Just a short walk away is Trattoria Trecolori, a family-owned Italian restaurant that’s been serving locals, tourists, and Broadway stars for years. It’s not just close to the theater district, it’s part of its rhythm. Think of it as the final act to your perfect night.

What Pairs with Wicked? The Best Italian Restaurant NYC, of Course

Let’s be honest, after flying monkeys and green-skinned heroines, you want something grounding, something warm. And that’s where Trattoria Trecolori comes in. This isn't a spot that tries too hard. It’s the kind of place where you sit down and immediately feel taken care of. Like someone cast a comfort spell on you.

Whether you’re seeing Wicked, The Lion King, or Back to the Future, your Broadway night deserves a meal worthy of the experience. That’s why locals call it the best Italian restaurant NYC has near the shows, because it consistently delivers.

A Menu That Hits All the Right Notes

Start with a classic Mozzarella in Carrozza. Golden, parmesan-crusted, and gently fried, just like Glinda would probably enjoy at a bubble-themed dinner party. Or go for the Fritto Misto, a crispy mix of calamari, shrimp, and zucchini that somehow tastes like applause.

Then there’s the pasta. Handmade, layered, and theatrical in the best way. The Lasagne alla Bolognese is a standout, with fennel sausage and veal ragu slow-cooked to perfection. Prefer seafood? The Linguine Nere alla Monsignore is a showstopper: black squid ink pasta with scallops, clams, shrimp, and mussels in a rich tomato sauce.

And let’s talk about dessert, because you can’t end a night like Wicked without something a little indulgent. The Pistachio Tartufo, with its striking green hue, feels like a nod to Elphaba herself. Wicked on stage, sweet on the plate.

Come for the Show, Stay for the Cannoli

At Trattoria Trecolori, the show doesn’t end when the curtain drops. The warm lighting, the smell of roasted garlic, and the gentle hum of conversation create a scene of their own.

And if you’re arriving before the show, the lunch menu is no less impressive. Sandwiches like the Pollo Parmigianaand Mortadella with burrata and artichoke aioli make for the perfect pre-theater fuel.

This place isn’t trendy for the sake of it. There’s no gimmick, just real Italian food, served with warmth, a great wine list, and yes, espresso martinis that might make you break into spontaneous song.

Getting There: No Broom Required

Trattoria Trecolori is located at 254 W 47th St, right in the heart of the Theater District. It's a three-minute walk from the Gershwin Theatre (Wicked), five minutes from the Minskoff (The Lion King), and surrounded by other iconic Broadway stages. Whether you’re in heels or sneakers, it’s the kind of convenient that makes you feel like a local.

Why Locals and Tourists Alike Love Trattoria

It’s not just about proximity. It’s about consistency. About walking into a place that remembers your order. About dishes that feel homemade but elevated. About Italian food that doesn’t try too hard, because it doesn’t need to.

There’s something inherently New York about Trattoria Trecolori: bold but classic, high-quality without the attitude, and always ready to serve whether it’s your first visit or your fiftieth.

Final Curtain Call

So, what pairs best with Broadway? A table full of handmade pasta, a glass of Italian wine, and that feeling of extending a special night just a little longer.

Whether you’re team Elphaba or team Glinda, there’s one thing everyone can agree on: Trattoria Trecolori is a standing ovation on a plate.